RT.com
24 Nov 2022, 15:47 GMT+10
Britain subjected its multi-billion-pound aid programs to US military goals and got mired in corruption and criminality, a report claims
Despite spending almost Pound 3.5 billion ($4.23 bn) in aid over two decades on building a functional state in Afghanistan, Britain mostly failed to achieve its goals, a government watchdog said in a damning report. A key misstep was prioritizing shifting US military objectives over stabilization efforts.
The review was released on Thursday by the Independent Commission for Aid Impact (ICAI). It awarded the Afghanistan effort the second-worst amber-red score under its four-grade system, based on "unrealistic objectives, flawed approaches and limited evidence of progress towards its strategic objectives." The document covered the period from 2014 to the fall of Kabul to the Taliban in August 2021.
The watchdog pointed the finger at the dominant role played by the US in Afghanistan and the UK's choice to put transatlantic relations ahead of the misgivings it had about Washington's policies.
"The US decided at an early stage to exclude the Taliban from the political process and instead pursue a military victory over them," the ICAI wrote. "As a result, the state-building project did not rest on a broad political agreement to make it legitimate among Afghan elites and the Afghan public, on whose support it depended."
Among other things, the UK pledged to co-fund the Afghanistan National Police (ANP). There were reports of widespread embezzlement and other forms of corruption as well as police brutality, arbitrary detention, torture, and extrajudicial killings by the ANP, the report noted. Funding the force may have provided some protection from Taliban incursions, but "the ANP did not develop a substantial civilian policing role."
"We found evidence of a number of attempts at senior levels to terminate the support, which were overruled at the highest levels of the UK government," the ICAI said.
The UK did achieve some positive changes by improving access to healthcare, fostering agricultural development, and particularly on women's rights, the report acknowledged. There is concern that much of the progress will be reversed under the Taliban's rule, but some experts interviewed "were cautiously optimistic that the efforts ... had helped create lasting pressure for social change."
Nevertheless, the aid programs suffered from a number of other issues, according to the review. They include reliance on parallel institutions staffed by consultants, the capture of the central government in Kabul by corrupt elite interests, Afghanistan's overwhelming reliance on foreign aid, and limited engagement with local leaders.
The ICAI expects the government to respond to its criticisms in January 2023.
(RT.com)
Get a daily dose of The UK News news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to The UK News.
More InformationSAN FRANCISCO, California: Grammarly is doubling down on AI-powered productivity tools with the acquisition of Superhuman, a sleek...
NEW YORK, New York -U.S. stock markets closed with broad gains on Thursday, led by strong performances in U.S. tech stocks, while European...
LONDON/STOCKHOLM: The Persson family is ramping up its investment in the H&M fashion empire, fueling renewed speculation about a potential...
PARIS, France: L'Oréal is making a fresh play in the booming premium haircare segment with a new acquisition. The French beauty conglomerate...
MENLO PARK, California: Robinhood is giving European investors a new way to tap into America's most prominent tech names — without...
NEW YORK, New York - U.S. stocks diverged on Wednesday for the second day in a row. The Standard and Poor's 500 hit a new all-time...
BEIJING, China: China's national soccer team may struggle to stir excitement, but its humanoid robots are drawing cheers — and not...
Kolkata (West Bengal) [India], July 4 (ANI): Mohun Bagan Super Giant's (MBSG) Dippendu Biswas is living the dream that every young...
Diogo Jota and his brother were killed just days after the Portuguese forward's wedding ...
New Delhi [India], July 3 (ANI): Indian Super League (ISL) side NorthEast United FC, on Wednesday, announced the departure of Spanish...
Florida [US], July 2 (ANI): Spanish giants Real Madrid and German club Borussia Dortmund on Wednesday became the last two teams to...
(250702) -- ATLANTA, July 2, 2025 (Xinhua) -- Supporters of CF Monterrey react before the round of 16 match between Borussia Dortmund...